Retirement and tax-advantaged accounts · Explainer

Roth IRA 5-year rules.
Two separate rules most people confuse.

READ4 min·UPDATED·APPLIES TOUnited States·LEVELIntermediate
For people doing Roth conversions or early Roth withdrawals. Sources are listed at the bottom of the page; check their dates before acting.

The Roth IRAIndividual Retirement Account (IRA)A retirement account with tax advantages and eligibility rules. Traditional IRA contributions may be deductible; taxable withdrawals generally enter income. Roth contributions use after-tax money, and qualified Roth withdrawals are tax-free.Full definition has two distinct 5-year rules. They apply to different situations and have different consequences. Confusing them leads to unexpected tax bills.

US-only. Roth IRA rules are part of the US Internal Revenue Code (IRC 408A).

Short answer

Rule 1: your Roth IRA must be 5 years old before earnings can be withdrawn tax-free. Rule 2: each Roth conversionRoth conversionMoving eligible retirement money into a Roth account. Pre-tax amounts and earnings generally create taxable income; nondeductible basis is treated under the applicable aggregation rules. Conversions can affect tax brackets and income-based costs, and separate withdrawal rules apply.Full definition has its own separate 5-year clock before converted funds can be withdrawn penalty-free. Contributions are always accessible without penalty or tax. The two clocks operate independently.

Section 1 · The two rules

Rule 1: The earnings rule

  • Applies to: tax-free withdrawal of EARNINGS (growth).
  • Clock starts: January 1 of the tax year of your first contribution to any Roth IRA, or of your first conversion if that came earlier. A prior-year contribution made by the April deadline counts for the prior year.
  • Once the clock is satisfied AND you are 59½+: earnings come out tax-free.
  • If you withdraw earnings early: income tax + 10% penalty (with some exceptions).
  • Key: one clock for all your Roth IRAs, not per account.

Rule 2: The conversion rule

  • Applies to: penalty-free withdrawal of CONVERTED FUNDS (not contributions, not earnings).
  • Clock starts: January 1 of the year each conversion was made.
  • Withdraw converted funds before 5 years AND before 59½: 10% penalty (no income tax, since tax was already paid at conversion, but the penalty applies).
  • After 59½: the 5-year clock on conversions does not matter. Withdrawals are penalty-free.
  • Key: EACH CONVERSION has its own 5-year clock ×DON'T TRUST, VERIFYClaim: Roth IRA has two separate 5-year rules: one for earnings (tied to the first Roth contribution) and one for each conversion.Verify at: IRS Publication 590-B ↗ Source 1 in the list belowPub 590-B contains the ordering rules and the two 5-year clocks..

Section 2 · The ordering rules

When you withdraw from a Roth IRA, the IRS treats the money as coming out in this order:

  1. Contributions first (always tax and penalty-free).
  2. Conversions next (by year, oldest first).
  3. Earnings last (may be taxed and penalized).

This ordering is critical for early retirees using the Roth conversion ladder. Contributions come out first (always accessible). Then the oldest conversions (penalty-free once 5 years old, or at 59½). Earnings are last (typically not touched until 59½).

Which money leaves first, and which clock applies
  1. Contributionsno clockAlways tax and penalty-free.
  2. Conversions, oldest firsta clock eachRule 2: a 5-year clock for each conversion:2026 to 20312027 to 20322028 to 2033and so onPenalty-free once its 5 years pass or at 59½+. Before both: 10% penalty, no income tax.
  3. Earningsone clockRule 1: one 5-year clock for all Roth IRAs:First contribution or conversion year + 5 yearsTax-free once the clock is satisfied and you are 59½+.Taken early: income tax + 10% penalty, with some exceptions.
Clocks start January 1 of the conversion year or first contribution year. Conversion years follow the ladder example below.
The IRS treats Roth IRA withdrawals as coming out in a fixed order: contributions, then conversions oldest first, then earnings. Contributions have no clock, every conversion runs its own 5-year clock, and all earnings share one clock plus the 59½ test.

Section 3 · The conversion ladder in practice

Example with the Roth conversion ladder:

CONVERSION-LADDER MECHANICS
  • 2026: Convert $40,000 from Traditional IRA to Roth. Clock starts for this conversion: January 1, 2026.
  • 2027: Convert another $40,000. Separate clock: January 1, 2027.
  • 2028, 2029, 2030: Continue annual conversions, each with its own clock.
  • 2031: Withdraw $40,000 from the 2026 conversion. Five years have passed. Penalty-free access (assuming under 59½, the 5-year rule protects from the 10% penalty; tax was paid at conversion).

This is the mechanic behind the Roth conversion ladder for early retirees. See The Roth Conversion Ladder for the full strategy.

RELATED PAGES
Roth IRA Concepts · the basics Backdoor Roth · for high earners Roth Conversion Ladder · the strategy itself Rule of 55 · another early-access path 72(t) SEPP · the IRA-side equivalent FIRE · the broader early-retirement plan

Where to go from here

Do next

Roth Conversion Calculator

Estimate how much to convert this year based on your bracket.

Read next

Roth Conversions

The full case for converting and the mechanics behind both clocks.

Explore further

Sources

Verify badges in the text link to these sources. Figures, rates and rules change: check each source’s date before acting on it.

  1. IRS Publication 590-B. Distributions from Individual Retirement Arrangements (IRAs) · irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p590b.pdf. ↩

Last updated . Educational content, not financial advice. Disclosures · How pages are reviewed

Subscribe via RSS for new articles.