A history of
every major mistake.

1913 · Creation

In November 1910, a handful of bankers and Treasury officials snuck off to Jekyll Island, Georgia, to draft what would become the Federal Reserve System^[1]. Senator Nelson Aldrich, Paul Warburg of Kuhn, Loeb & Co., Frank Vanderlip of National City Bank. They kept it quiet on purpose: a bill openly written by bankers would have been torched in public. Dressed up as a Congressional product, it passed.

Wilson signed the Federal Reserve Act on December 23, 1913. The original job was simple: backstop banks after the 1907 Panic. Congress bolted on the dual mandate (maximum employment plus price stability) in 1977. What the Fed does today, yield-curve jawboning, $9T balance sheets, emergency lending facilities to non-banks, would be unrecognizable to the people who designed it.

1920s · Easy money and the setup

The Fed kept rates low through most of the 1920s, supporting Britain's doomed attempt to return to gold at pre-war parity. Credit expanded rapidly. Stock market speculation ballooned. The Dow rose from 63 in 1921 to 381 by September 1929, a six-fold increase in eight years. The Fed recognized the bubble late and began raising rates in 1928, but by then the correction was inevitable.

1929–1933 · The Great Depression mistake

Milton Friedman and Anna Schwartz, in A Monetary History of the United States, 1867–1960 (1963), documented that the Fed's decision to allow the money supply to contract by roughly one-third between 1929 and 1933 turned a recession into a depression^[2]. Thousands of banks failed without Fed intervention. Depositors lost savings. Credit collapsed. The real economy contracted by about 27% from peak to trough.

Twenty years later, Bernanke, by then Fed chair, replicated the solution he had studied, unleashing QE in 2008. The promise "we won't do it again" turned out to mean "we will print whatever it takes to prevent the next deflationary spiral," regardless of what that costs in currency debasement.

1960s–1970s · The Great Inflation

Arthur Burns chaired the Fed from 1970 to 1978 under Nixon, Ford, and Carter. Declassified tapes and memos released decades later document political pressure from Nixon to keep rates low ahead of the 1972 reelection^[3]. Burns capitulated. Easy money, combined with the 1973 oil embargo and wage-price controls, produced persistent double-digit inflation by the late 1970s.

CPI peaked near 14% in 1980^[4]. Inflation expectations were entrenched. The Fed had spent a decade proving it would not fight inflation seriously, and markets had adjusted accordingly. Breaking that psychology required someone willing to cause a recession on purpose.

1979–1987 · The Volcker shock

Volcker, appointed by Jimmy Carter in August 1979, raised the federal funds rate to a peak of about 20% in June 1981^[5]. The result was the 1981–1982 recession, the sharpest since the Great Depression. Unemployment peaked above 10%. Farm foreclosures surged. Latin American countries, many of whom had borrowed in dollars, faced debt crises.

It worked. Inflation fell from 14% to 3% by 1983. Inflation expectations reset. Volcker is the one Fed chair in modern history who accepted a severe recession as the price of breaking entrenched inflation. He is also the last one who had full political cover to do so. No subsequent Fed chair has been willing to match that commitment when markets have pushed back.

1987–2006 · Greenspan and the Put

Alan Greenspan chaired the Fed for 19 years. His response to every major market stress, the 1987 crash, the 1998 LTCM collapse, the 2000 dot-com bust, the 2001 recession, was to cut rates. Markets noticed. The "Greenspan put" became shorthand for the assumption that the Fed would always bail out falling asset prices.

The structural consequence was moral hazard. If investors believed the Fed would always cushion the downside, risk-taking rationally increased. This produced the housing bubble of the mid-2000s, the securitization excesses, and ultimately the 2008 financial crisis.

He then ran the institution he warned about for 19 years. The man who wrote that gold was the only defense against inflationary confiscation presided over the largest credit expansion in history.

2008 · The financial crisis response

Ben Bernanke, who had studied the Depression, refused to let the 2008 banking panic repeat it. The Fed launched the first quantitative easing program, buying Treasuries and mortgage-backed securities. The balance sheet grew from roughly $900 billion pre-crisis to $4.5 trillion by late 2014^[6].

The banking system was saved. Most banks recovered. Foreclosed homeowners were not. The bailout was structural, directed at the balance sheets of financial institutions rather than the households who had lost their homes. The resulting wealth divergence drove a decade of political realignment on both left and right.

Bernanke was awarded the 2022 Nobel Prize in Economics, in part for his research on the Depression and the banking channel. He won the prize for understanding the problem he then replicated the solution to.

2018 · The attempt to normalize

Jerome Powell, appointed in February 2018, tried to normalize policy. The Fed raised rates to 2.25–2.50% by December 2018 and began reducing the balance sheet through quantitative tightening. Markets threw a tantrum in the fourth quarter of 2018, the S&P 500 fell roughly 20% from peak to trough^[7]. Powell reversed course in January 2019, pausing hikes and eventually cutting rates three times by October. The episode established what markets already suspected: rates could not return to pre-2008 levels without breaking something.

2020–2022 · COVID QE and the transitory mistake

The Fed responded to the COVID lockdowns with $120 billion per month in asset purchases, cutting rates to zero, and opening unprecedented emergency facilities. M2 grew 41% in 25 months. The balance sheet expanded from ~$4.2T to a peak near $8.97T by April 2022^[6].

Starting in mid-2021, as inflation accelerated, Powell and his colleagues characterized the increases as "transitory." The word was used in public statements for nearly nine months. CPI peaked at 9.1% in June 2022^[8]. "Transitory" was retired from Fed vocabulary in November 2021.

The communication failure was consequential. Markets and businesses had been pricing in transitory inflation. When the Fed shifted abruptly to aggressive hiking, the adjustment was violent.

2022–2023 · The fastest hike cycle in 40 years

Between March 2022 and July 2023, the Fed raised the federal funds rate from 0–0.25% to 5.25–5.50%, the fastest pace since the early 1980s^[5]. Banks that had loaded up on long-duration Treasuries and mortgage-backed securities during the zero-rate era faced massive mark-to-market losses.

Silicon Valley Bank collapsed in March 2023, taking Signature Bank and First Republic with it. The second-largest bank failure in U.S. history was triggered by unrealized losses on Treasury holdings, assets the banks had bought because the Fed had pushed yields to zero, then saw repriced when the Fed hiked^[9]. The Fed opened the Bank Term Funding Program to provide emergency liquidity.

The pattern

Over 112 years the cycle has repeated with growing amplitude:

1. Cut rates and print money to cushion a downturn or prevent a crisis.
2. Asset prices inflate as cheap money flows into stocks, housing, and risk assets.
3. Recovery is declared based on the wealth effect and equity markets.
4. Attempt to normalize rates and balance sheet.
5. Markets break because debt has grown relative to income at every level.
6. Return to step 1, with more intervention required each time.

Each cycle requires more intervention than the last because the cumulative debt pile has grown and each prior intervention taught markets that the Fed would step in again. The balance sheet went from $900B (2007) to $4.5T (2014) to $8.97T (2022). It has never returned to pre-crisis levels. It probably never will.