SCHD vs VYM: two dividend ETFs, two different strategies.

Side by side

Selection methodology

SCHD: quality screen

SCHD tracks the Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 Index. The index applies a multi-step quality screen verify×DON'T TRUST, VERIFYClaim: SCHD tracks the Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 Index using a multi-factor quality screen.Verify at: Schwab SCHD page ↗ · Dow Jones methodology ↗Index methodology is publicly documented by S&P Dow Jones Indices. Confirm against the methodology PDF before relying on this.:

1. Universe: US companies with at least 10 consecutive years of dividend payments.
2. Filter: cash-flow-to-debt ratio, return on equity, dividend yield, and 5-year dividend growth rate, each ranked.
3. Top 100 by composite score, weighted by dividend yield, capped at 4% per holding and 25% per sector.
4. Annual reconstitution in March.

VYM: broad above-average yield

VYM tracks the FTSE High Dividend Yield Index. The selection is simpler: take all US dividend-paying stocks, exclude REITsReal Estate Investment Trust (REIT)A company that owns income-producing real estate and must distribute at least 90% of taxable income as dividends. REIT dividends are taxed as ordinary income, not the lower qualified dividend rate, making REITs most efficient in tax-advantaged accounts., rank by forecast 12-month dividend yield, take the top 50% by aggregate yield. Cap-weighted within. The result is approximately 440 holdings, much broader than SCHD, with no explicit quality screen and no consecutive-payment requirement.

Sector overlap and concentration

The two funds have a substantial overlap (roughly 70% of SCHD holdings appear in VYM) but with very different weights. Approximate sector mix as of May 2026:

SCHD's overweight in defensive sectors (Consumer Staples, Health Care) and underweight in Financials gives it lower correlation with broad market drawdowns. VYM's heavier weight in Financials and Cyclicals makes it more market-like.

10-year rolling returns

SCHD launched in October 2011; VYM launched in November 2006. Over their joint history (2011-2026), the 10-year rolling total returns have favored SCHD by a small but persistent margin verify×DON'T TRUST, VERIFYClaim: SCHD's 10-year trailing total return has averaged ~0.5-1.5% higher than VYM through May 2026.Verify at: Portfolio Visualizer ↗ · Total Real Returns ↗Both ETFs publish total return data on their fund pages. Confirm specific window before publishing.:

The total-return picture: SCHD has slightly outperformed VYM, both have slightly underperformed broad market (S&P 500) over the last decade. The dividend-focused approach gives up some total return for the income tilt.

Dividend growth rates

For income-stage investors, the rate at which dividends grow over time matters more than the current yield.

• SCHD 10-year dividend CAGR: approximately 11%. The quality-screen methodology means SCHD systematically tilts toward dividend growers.
• VYM 10-year dividend CAGR: approximately 6-7%. The yield-focused methodology captures high payers but doesn't filter for growth.

The compounding implication over a 20-year retirement: a dividend stream growing at 11% doubles roughly every 6.5 years; a stream at 6.5% doubles every 11 years. Over a long retirement that's a meaningfully different income trajectory.

Tax efficiency

Both funds distribute qualified dividends from US corporations, taxed at long-term capital gainscapital gainsThe profit from selling an asset for more than you paid for it. Taxed differently depending on how long you held the asset. rates (0/15/20) at the federal level. The 3-4% yield is more than triple what an S&P 500 fund pays. In a taxable account this is an annual drag relative to a growth-tilted strategy.

In an IRAIndividual Retirement Account (IRA)A personal retirement savings account with tax advantages. Two main types: Traditional (tax now, pay later) and Roth (pay now, tax-free forever).Full definition or 401(k), dividends are not currently taxable. SCHD and VYM are most tax-efficient when held in tax-advantaged accounts. For accumulators in their 30s and 40s in taxable accounts, broad-market funds (VTI, FZROX, VOO) typically generate less current tax drag.

Who should hold each

• Pick SCHD if: you want a quality-screened dividend strategy with stronger historical dividend growth, lower financials exposure, and a willingness to accept slightly higher single-stock concentration (top 10 holdings ~40% of fund).
• Pick VYM if: you prefer broader diversificationdiversificationSpreading investments across different assets so a drop in one doesn't devastate your entire portfolio.Full definition across 440 holdings, simpler methodology, and acceptance of slower dividend growth in exchange for a slightly higher initial yield in some periods.
• Pick neither if: you are an accumulator (under 50, building wealth, not yet drawing income). Both fund types create unnecessary current-tax drag versus broad-market accumulation funds.

Common questions

Related reading

• VOO vs SPY vs IVV · the S&P 500 comparison
• Index funds
• Broader index fund comparison
• Bonds explainer
• FIRE · how withdrawal strategies interact with dividend vs total-return frameworks